close
close

Slide shared by New Brunswick Premier: ‘Blatant misrepresentation’ of sexual health presentation

St. John’s, Netherlands

ST. JOHN’S, NL — The sex education slide that enraged New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs is the first of more than 100 slides in a presentation on healthy relationships and sexual health that will be shown to high school students across the country, reporters learned Friday.

Teresa Norris, president of Montreal-based HPV Global Action, led the media through the presentation to provide context for the single opening slide, which Higgs shared on social media last week and called “clearly inappropriate.”

The screenshot of the slide contains questions such as “Do girls masturbate?” and “Is anal sex good or bad?”

Norris explained that the questions are meant to get attention, but also to show teens that such questions are normal and that presenting them will give them the information they need to find answers. She said teens are asking these questions whether parents and educators know it or not.

“And HPV Global is committed to providing people who are looking for an answer with an appropriate, age-appropriate, fact-based answer and not … misinformation like they find online,” Norris said in an interview.

Higgs shared a screenshot of the slide on X (formerly Twitter) last week and wrote that HPV Global would no longer be allowed to be presented in schools in the province “effective immediately.”

He also claimed that the material was not part of the province’s curriculum. However, a government website states that puberty, gender identity, sexual orientation and healthy romantic and sexual relationships are discussed in a high school course on individual and family well-being. Higgs later admitted that he had not seen the presentation in its entirety.

On Friday, Norris explained that the slide sets the stage for her presentation, titled “Healthy Relationships 101,” and is not an overview of what will be discussed. The next few slides tell her own story of losing her best friend to cervical cancer, a story she uses to build a connection with her audience and reinforce that some of what they are about to learn about sexual health could save a life.

The presentation then discusses healthy and unhealthy friendships and relationship behaviors, sexuality and puberty, consent, abstinence, and sexually transmitted diseases. It explains that it’s OK for teens to feel uncomfortable about sex or to ask questions about it and their own sexual identity. It discusses what it means to be sexually active, which sexually transmitted diseases can and cannot be cured, and how you get them and how to prevent them.

Anal sex is only discussed in this context because it is a form of sex and, like any other, it carries risks, Norris said.

All of these problems are related to HPV, a sexually transmitted disease that can cause a number of cancers, including cervical cancer. She recommends that students get vaccinated against the virus and be aware that symptoms can appear years after the initial infection.

Norris also encourages students to remind their mothers to get tested regularly for HPV. In more than two decades of giving various versions of this presentation in schools across the country, 12 teens have come back to her and told her that their mothers got tested at her urging and were found to have a health problem, she said.

Steve Outhouse, a spokesman for Higgs, said Norris offered to give government officials an abbreviated version of her presentation, but they declined. He asked for her slides instead, which she declined. But he said he would accept Norris’ offer to give the full presentation.

Outhouse said the main problem was that parents were not informed of the presentation or given a chance to comment on its contents. He acknowledged that this could be a problem with the school or the Department of Education rather than Norris’ group, and said the government was still investigating what happened.

Higgs’ social media post was linked to a poll that showed a screenshot of the presentation’s opening slide and asked how concerned respondents were about “this content being shared with high school students without their parents’ knowledge.”

Outhouse said more than 3,200 people responded and 82 percent said they were very concerned.

Norris said that focusing on a single slide without considering the context of her entire presentation misses the point.

“I have never experienced such a gross misrepresentation of my work in my entire career,” she said of Higgs’ reaction.

She fears his promise to ban her group from performing in the province will have a chilling effect on educators in New Brunswick and across the country.

“We should put teenagers at the centre of the current discussion,” she said. “What happens if we don’t give teenagers space to ask questions and express concerns?”

Norris said she works with education and health officials in each region to make sure her presentations align with the curriculum and resources of the students she is speaking to. Education officials — which can be teachers, principals or school board representatives — sign a consent form allowing HPV Global to participate in the presentation. They sign their signature after reading a detailed presentation outline, she said.

“There was no surprise” in New Brunswick, she said, adding that her group has been performing in the province’s schools for years.

Norris said she hopes to meet with provincial education officials and discuss the issue.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 31, 2024.

Sarah Smellie, The Canadian Press