Breaking down the greatest undrafted Buffalo Bills players of all time

Jason Peters could easily be number one on this list, and I wouldn’t argue too much. He came to the Bills in 2004, going undrafted largely because he was listed as a tight end and had never played offensive tackle before signing his rookie free agent contract . Coming out of high school, he was a defensive tackle and the Arkansas Razorbacks moved him to tight end. After joining the Bills, it took a few seasons to settle down on the offensive line, starting only 11 games in the first two seasons.

During his five seasons in Buffalo, he twice earned second-team All-Pro honors and was a two-time Pro Bowler. He started 55 games for the Bills and I would have ranked him higher if he had been with Buffalo longer. Most of his career was spent with the Philadelphia Eagles after the Bills traded him in a deal that included multiple draft picks, one of which was used to select Bills center Eric Wood in the first round. Peters is among Gil Brandt’s top 30 undrafted players in league history, at number 22.